Outcome of House of Lords debate
A key debate on amendments relating to legal aid for children and young people took place in Parliament earlier this week as part of the House of Lords Committee Stage of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Bill. There was powerful support for protecting the rights of children and vulnerable young people from Peers of all parties, including Baroness Benjamin (Floella, TV presenter, LD), Baroness Eaton (recently retired Chair of the LGA, Con), Baroness Butler-Sloss (ex-High Court judge, Cross-bencher) and Lord Ramsbotham (ex-Chief Inspector of Prisons, Cross-bencher). We are particularly grateful to Baroness Massey (Lab) and Baroness Howe (Cross-bencher), who tabled and spoke to our amendments protecting young people up to the age of 24. Many Peers quoted (sometimes extensively) from JustRights briefings and reports.
No peers spoke against the amendments and the Minister, Lord McNally, cut a lonely figure as he made his fairly feeble response, in which he offered no concessions, but he did promise to give full consideration to the points made. All the amendments were withdrawn without a vote, but there was clearly sufficient support for us to feel confident that many of the issues will come back before the House at Report Stage.
We attach edited extracts of the debate from Hansard.
Or you can view the full two hour debate on the BBC website here.
What happens next with the Bill?
The Committee Stage in the House of Lords will continue over the next couple of weeks. Most of the debates on legal aid have already taken place and attention will now turn to other aspects of the Bill, including sentencing reforms.
The Report Stage of the Bill is expected to start in 5-6 weeks’ time. This is where absolutely crucial votes on amendments will be taken, as has happened recently with the Welfare Reform Bill. There are some signs already that there could be significant Tory and Lib Dem rebellions over the legal aid changes if the Government fails to offer significant concessions.
JustRights will now have to think about which amendments we want to be discussed again at the Report Stage of the Bill, and which we might be able to encourage Peers to press to a vote. If you want to be part of our deliberations on this, don’t hesitate to contact one of us.
There’s still a lot of work to be done if we’re going to be ultimately successful with our campaign, but we remain optimistic – and this is where it gets exciting, so if you want to work more closely with us in the final stages, just let us know.
Letter to Sarah Teather
I attach a letter JustRights intends to send next week to Sarah Teather MP, Minister of State for Children and Families. The letter raises our concerns about the impact of the Legal Aid Bill on children and young people and how the legal aid cuts threaten to break a commitment she gave that the Government will give due consideration to the UNCRC when making new policy and legislation.
Lords Bill Cttee 16.01.12.docx
Sarah Teather MP.docx